This really is a question of causes. Did no-fault divorce cause the weakening of marriage and family ties? Or does no-fault divorce expose an inconvenient truth hidden by strictly enforced marriage arrangements? Critics of no-fault divorce often blame women and feminism, since women file most divorces. Yet research suggests men are often decisive factors in attempts to salvage troubled marriages. To claim no-fault divorce itself caused the destruction of the family ignores deeper problems that created the demand for legal change in the first place.
Moreover, a libertarian society doesn't have zero constraints on marriage and divorce. Aside from social norms developing away from authoritarian views of marriage and toward individual choice---i.e., parent-arranged marriages would likely decrease, and child marriage could stand a chance of being legally prohibited (because free religious practice cannot violate self-ownership and the NAP)---prenuptial agreements would likely increase dramatically. Prenuptial agreements are a longstanding practice, including in ancient Israel. A marriage contract known as a ketubah, which involved a bride price, dowry, etc., was set aside along with conditions. In the case of a husband's death or unjust divorce, the woman would receive that money as a financial safety net. If she initiated an unjust divorce, the man would receive it.
As usual, this objection boils down to a failure to imagine legal and social orders outside the authoritarian state apparatus. And that's no objection.
This question is from Faith Seeking Freedom: Updated & Expanded, available in paperback, PDF, and Kindle.
