Accreditation is voluntary, though states may endorse certain agencies aligned with their policies while ignoring others. Tax-funded schools are typically required to be accredited, while private schools choose agencies that best fit their model and curriculum. These agencies act as third-party certifiers, signaling oversight to parents. The quality of that oversight varies---some are mere rubber stamps, while others maintain high standards. And just because a government education department has endorsed a particular accrediting agency, doesn't mean that agency is even worth its salt. In a free market, competition among agencies creates the incentive to uphold diligent and trustworthy standards.
Furthermore, accreditation is not required for college entrance or for achieving valid diplomas. Those interested in the academic acumen of an applicant will take into consideration a variety of factors, including standardized test scores like the SAT or ACT, application essays and interviews, personal recommendations, portfolios of work, and so on. In recent years, the conventional Carnegie unit and GPA system is becoming meaningless, as public schools have reoriented their programs to "teach to the test."
Education in a free society would benefit both from innovation and a variety of models, programs, curricula, and so forth. Eliminate compulsory education requirements, and more experiences can count as learning. Will there be a need for some oversight over educational institutions claiming they have a sound education model? Sure. But that's already provided for by the market.
This question is from Faith Seeking Freedom: Updated & Expanded, available in paperback, PDF, and Kindle.
